3 stars: I'm not sure to buy it. Some pointers about what I dislike: mind you, I have read the free chapter only. If you think it's unfair to judge it by only that, think again. First, what is going on with 3 woman captains already? 2 pirate ones and one admiral. That is very unlikely for that time period. You can of course have this as the norm in the book but a mild introduction would have been nice, something like \
5 stars: Haven't read it yet, just know it deserves 5 stars.
5 stars: When's the sequel
5 stars: Very Good, As Always
5 stars: Havent read it but the theme is on point
...