5 stars: Had this game for a while now and really enjoying the grind. The lack of microtransactions is refreshing and competitive play gives rewards. Gotta say good job on this one it's been a fun one!
4 stars: Extremely good. Minor bugs and too long of a grind but the consistent updates is a solid A-.
4 stars: The looting setting is on loot nothing by default so pretty sure that you just didnt notice it, an upgrade for gold gained by looting would be nice aswell.
3 stars: As someone else pointed out it plays very much like heroism lite, and there are just a select few conscious design decisions that strike me as unfriendly, were it not for them I would easily give it 4-5 but with them it does feel smaller and decidedly less fun than heroism, and more akin to your average mobile game.
3 stars: Glad you have made this its own thing, much prefer the auto style to the original idea. But please can you add a lot more character classes. Would really feel like a real dungeons and dragons style thing where we can choose many different party compositions, especially for tournaments. Would really add a lot to it. So much potential here! Edit: Already bored, no items, few skills, few classes. Just needs a lot more honestly.
2 stars: Can't login frequently. Very little progress. No real point.
2 stars: Horrible pathing and it's supposed to be an idle/afk game yet you have to unlock offline gains over a very long time with points. Seems like an identity crisis.