5 stars: Absolutely amazing and unique concept. I like that you can't just blaze through seasons and every decision on every day of the season actually matters in both the short and long term. Hoping it doesn't end up as just another game where you can really only go up and up as time goes on. That's dull eventually. Need it to be a proper challenge. Loving it after 2 seasons so far though
5 stars: Great college football simulator. I wish it was a little easier to find or customize recruits though, it doesn't always feel like you can really build up your program as following a specific style of play. Eg, finding more run blocking o-linemen or pass rushing DTs. Also, more explanation on what the different stats do would be appreciated.
2 stars: I really want this to be decent. But instead, once you understand how to navigate, it's 80% watching it roll a play by play of a game day you have no control over after picking your scheme. And then you can maybe gain 2 or three skill points a season. It needs the ability to toggle off the play by play and just give results, and an update to the play algorithm.
...