5 stars: This is an awesome creative game that mixes alchemy with town building and you can literally go anywhere you want with anything to build a one of a kind world. Only thing that's been irritating me is any time I watch a video to double my rewards, it'll finish the video then kick me out of the game and I don't get the double rewards. Other than that, great game.
4 stars: I am liking it except it is a little hard to understand how to create different terrains and new land. I restarted twice and am getting the hang of it. We'll see how it goes.
4 stars: It's ok. Nice discovery system encourages you to try new combinations. But it takes longer and longer to upgrade or get resources, like many many many continuous improvement games. That makes it a sit and wait game. At only level 5 I'm waiting 20 minutes to get an 8th human? Horrible. But still a fun time waster, thus the 4/5.
2 stars: It could be a great game. The only issues that i have is that you have to manually replace the resources (i.e. stone, trees) each time or the builders go idle. Why not regenerate? And you have to manually collect each item from the crafting. You have to manually set each task. I love the creativity of this game, the openness, the challenge.
...