5 stars: Just started playing the game but so far it's pretty impressive. Good quality graphics, decently thought out story line, etc. I like how each character has a little bio about them, and some characters have multiple perks as a captain/leader once you upgrade them enough times. Overall good game, would definitely recommend checking it out
4 stars: Best game of this genre I have played. The building is quick, easy and lacks the tedium of most of the others in this genre. Also so far no constant tedium of attacks from other players - just from npcs. Only played for a couple of hours and hope that there will be no ugly surprises in the future.
3 stars: This game needs adjusting because losing troops as an attacker is getting too expensive for replacing. It encourages stronger players to prey on the weak for a sure thing kills. One solution would be to adjust the game so attacking would wound troops rather than kill them. Or significantly lower the resource cost and time to recoup.
...