5 stars: I went into this game thinking that it would be mostly pay to win. Although I see some people who have an advantage from paying, you can do completely fine without paying for anything. Great game!
4 stars: Good game. Always upgrading so there is always down time. Outer realms is fun if it lets you in when your already set up there. Don't understand why troops are rewarded and paid for only to starve and run off. Still many areas of the game needs fixing. Other than that it's very fun and relaxing.
4 stars: Too much focus on PvP. Not realistic penalty for PVP random attacks. If it wants to be a challenge then hit the PVP with a penalty equal to 2x the damage/glory/honor/fire to what they attempted to do to a non PVP player. Don't charge $ to the non just because they don't like drive by shooting or bullies.
3 stars: Even the briefest interruption in your wifi connection will cause the game to crash. And the
2 stars: Played this game for 10 years unless you're willing to spend lots of money to pay to play the big spenders Will destroy you over and over again. Sorry for the bad new...
...