5 stars: Excellent. Great for casual gamers seeking to play battle ship, but lots of great features to spice things up a little bit for those seeking a bit more. Solid animations, sounds and voice overs. Really just wanted to play battleship but found myself quickly sucked into the customizing after being pleasantly surprized with the simple and yet satisfying game play. The vibration for each hit, is a huge plus for me as well.
5 stars: This is, so far an awesome
4 stars: too many ads. otherwise, pretty good. Edit: the ads are gone with a one time payment rather than a subscription, which I'm super happy about. Upping my rating from your 3 to 4. The last star is out of reach because I don't support the micro transaction model. I'd much rather pay once for a game i like and have every part of it in one go.
2 stars: I don't like the fact that it tells you which ship is sunk. There is a strategy where you can make the opponent think he sunk your 4 length but really got your 3 length and one on another ship.
...