4 stars: I changed my 3 star to a 4 star just for the replay value it has. It's a good story, great character writing, great writing in general, and the illustrations! Dont get me started on the illustrations. BUT, although there is high replay value, after about ch. 2 or 3, it is notably rushed. The ending is unsatisfying compared to the rest of the story, and I got invested in my character, only for it to really not mean in the end.
4 stars: Definitely going to be a polarizing one. I personally loved it but wouldn't recommend it to many. The plot was kind of all over the place and vague, I did struggle a bit to keep up. But this is more cerebral. Very introspective, lots of options to flesh out your PC mentally and study their motivations. It's also very sad, very melancholy. Even the \
5 stars: It's a pretty good representation of VtM's setting concepts and aesthetics, and the only interactive fiction set outside North America currently. Some turns of phrase are really good. It would be cool if more clans were added, but I think this is the only IF with Malkavians -- note that your clan is seemingly determined by your first two chosen disciplines. Auspex and Dominate results in a Tremere, so you need Obscuration for a Malk.
4 stars: Its a good story, though sadly short. Its a shame the first VTM story released by COG that allows you to play Malkavian leaves you wanting more. The writing is good though and the author is quite good at setting a scene. Though for ...