5 stars: Nice graphics, good gui. There's match 3 as a side game but the main gameplay is still logging in everyday and watching a clock. No external ads but there are internal nag screens for mtx. It's a recent game of the 4X/idle genre and it doesn't have annoying flaws that could turn people away. Also big plus for the portrait orientation.
4 stars: The rewards system seems generous at first; but stamina and action points regenerate slowly. The game can be fun even if not spending a lot of money. There is a learning curve involved. Note that other players can attack you, but you can group with others for protection (alliance). It's easy to get help. Negatives: drama amongst players, huge
3 stars: I loved the graphics and the puzzles. But after awhile it got boring. Like most apps, it's filled with big coiners in the top 10 alliances taking over the server, excessive attacks on lower level players from higher level players. The events are fun, and easy to level up your kingdom but it just didn't keep my interests very long.
3 stars: Fun but to much a clone of so many other apps. Sure the story and graphics are different, but the plan of action is exactly like so many others. One huge plus however, is the ability to organize and move ALL your buildings. This plus does indeed make this app better than most.
...