4 stars: Balance is a little off (you can level very fast, then it becomes much slower to progress). Also lots of rewards, all over the place, and you can miss some due to timers. Some of the level requirements are frustrating (beat an encampment seemed to require an alliance and low level encampments are rare!) But ... good game.
3 stars: It's definitely not as advertised, although the shooting puzzle is in the game is very rare that your able to access it. That being said it's a building game, just like all the others. I will however admit this game is very pretty and the music is relaxing. If you find an active clan/alliance to join you really don't need to buy any of the multiple add-ons that are always being offered.
2 stars: Nice graphics, but the game is boring and empty. I spent 95% of the time collecting rewards and reading scenes. Shooting levels take like 2 seconds to complete, and again you click endless rewards to progress. I just wanted to shoot like in the ad. After the first chapter, the game tries to sell you even more rewards for real money. What a disappointment.
...